THEATER OF BLOODY HORROR
            by Vanessa Cortez, staff writer. 
            [October 24, 2003] 
              
              
              
              
             [WeeklyUniverse.com]  Eyes
              gouged out from screaming women! Legs and arms hacked off! Blood splashing into spectators' faces! And people paid to see
                it!!!  
            They
              were the sicko fans of the Grand Guignol, a bizarre school of theater created
              over 100 years ago in that capital of world culture -- France!  
            But
              don't blame the French! Rich and famous from around the world came
              to see it, according to Mel Gordon's Grand
                Guignol: Theatre Of Fear And Terror, his stomach-churning history of
              the twisted side of theater. 
            Although
  Oscar Méténier founded the Grand Guignol in gay Paris in
  1897, Gordon reveals that sickos have always thrilled to gory theater. 
  Prehistoric shamans entertained the tribe by mutilating their own bodies! Ancient Egyptians and "Amerinds" (aka Indians, aka "Native Americans")
  practiced both symbolic -- and real! -- ritual sacrifice on animals
  and on live screaming humans! And medieval Europeans had their
  own version of special effects -- bloody animal organs and limbs used as
  stage props for human gore! 
              
             * Blame France
              
            Many things
              French inspired the Grand Guignol. During the French Revolution's
              Reign of Terror, writes Gordon, "freshly-guillotined corpses were manipulated
              like oversized puppets in grotesque comedies." Even more shockingly, Grand
                Guignol means Big Puppet!!!                         
            By the
  1810s, melodramas about and for Paris's working class opened at the rate
  of 70 a month!  These were vulgar, potty-mouthed plays with evil rich
  villains oppressing the noble poor. But heart-warmingly, happy endings
  were mandatory, making these the Harlequin romances of their day! But shockingly, the Grand Guignol would drop the happy endings -- but
    keep the potty-mouthed vulgarity!  
            Another
  inspiration were faits divers, one-sheet newspapers about grisly
  crimes. Grand Guignol plays would also dramatize sicko crimes -- making
  the Guignol an early form of today's "true crime" genre!  
But America
  too influenced the Grand Guignol -- through our very own Edgar Allen Poe!
  -- who inspired a generation of French writers! 
  
    
    
 * Sicko Science
  
Science inspired
  the Grand Guignol through Naturalism, which was an aesthetic movement advocating
  "scientific" theater. Naturalists insisted that art, when depicting
  people, must use the latest findings in genetics, psychology, and environment. Darwin, Freud, and Weber helped inspire Naturalism. (In addition
  to the Guignol, Naturalism eventually inspired Stalislavsky's "Method acting"!) 
 Grand
  Guignol founder Méténier had a morbidly depraved "interest"
  in science. Gordon writes that Méténier "scoured Paris'
  menacing red-light and working-class slum districts for over six years in a scientific search for naturalist material." [our italics] 
Before
      opening his sickie Guignol, Méténier wrote for Théâtre
      Libre, casting "real criminal types to play themselves in minor
      parts."! [our italics]  
Méténier's
  twisted "research" let him write "authentic dialogue" for "lowlife play
  figures, many of whom were based on real persons," says Gordon. "He
  found their instinctive and savage actions superior to the vain pretensions
  of Paris' bourgeois theatre-goers." 
Méténier
  was a huge hypocrite! His Guignol claimed to be exploding bourgeois taboos, pretensions, and
  hypocrisies, with the intent to offend middle and upper-class authority,
  manners, and sensibilities -- but most Guignol fans were bourgeois and
  blue-blood! Millionaires and aristocrats were regulars!  Gordon
  writes: "For premieres, audiences often attended in evening dresses and
  tuxedos, bringing their own champagne and glasses."!!!  
Not only
  audiences, but the Guignol's creators were society's crème de
    la crème. Méténier was a journalist and
  police bureaucrat -- who enjoyed watching private state executions! He had to visit red-light districts to "study" the underclass
  -- because there were no poor people where he lived!!!  
One of
  the Guignol's most honored and prolific playwrights, André de Lorde,
  was a physician's son! Even more shockingly, De Lorde was such a
  sicko that his writing partner was also his therapist! -- Dr. Alfred
  Binet of the Sorbonne!  
Much of
  the Guignol's high society success was due to Max Maurey, a sleazeball
  showman who bought the Guignol from Méténier in 1898 and
  ran it till 1915. Maurey ditched all pretense of a "scientific theatre"
  for pure gore and potty-mouthing! -- creating a venue where, Gordon writes,
  "every social taboo of good taste was cracked and shattered."!!!  
Always
  looking to ca$h-in on his potty-mouthed shows, Maurey spread false reports
  of patrons fainting from shock. Later Guignol producers advertised
  the hiring of in-house physicians, presaging B-movie producer William
    Castle. 
  
 * Loved by Commies, Nazis, the
  Rich
  
By 1910, the Grand
  Guignol was a world-renowned tourist attraction, recommended in Parisian
  guidebooks of every language! Sicko hordes from the leisure, professional,
  and intellectual classes came to gawk at the "authentic" underclass types
  on stage, thrilled by their own imagined wickedness at seeing the shattering
  of their own "taboos."  
But the
  rich weren't alone! One avid fan was a Vietnamese refugee working
  in Paris as a noodle & pastry cook -- Ho Chi Minh! -- who later became
  Commie boss of North Vietnam! Other fans included Nazi fatso Hermann
  Goering, who often enjoyed Guignol shows during Germany's Occupation of
  France. And shamefully, after the Liberation, the Guignol won over
  another
  fan -- U.S. General George Patton!  
Patton
  was an infamous potty-mouth in his own right -- once referring to the German's
  private bodily parts as n*ts. [sic!!!!!] 
  
    
    
* Censorship  
  
Gordon
  ends his
    book by saying we should study the Guignol because arts censorship
  is a growing issue. He chides "otherwise liberal" people who want
  government censorship of violence.  But apart from his brief Conclusion,
  Gordon almost never discusses censorship!  
Even more
  shockingly, while Gordon considers himself a liberal, when the does discuss
  censorship, he makes a great case against government arts funding! Gordon writes: "Théâtre Libre was under immense pressure to
  rid itself of both the naturalist mystery play and social documentary. Only because the Théâtre Libre ran itself as a private
    enterprise limited to individual subscribers were local censors held at
    bay." On the other hand, Méténier's In The Family was banned from public theaters.  
But most
  shockingly of all, the Guignol met more censorship in liberal Britain than
  in
  fascist Italy! (Yes, there were Guignol copycats!) Britain's
  SPCA tried to close a British Guignol, fearing (wrongly) that wolfhounds
  were mistreated. But Italy's Guignol "performed uninterrupted from
  1923 to 1928."  
Did the
  Italian Guignol finally close due to declining audiences or to Fascist
  censors? Gordon doesn't say! -- although he says elsewhere that
  by the 1930s the novelty had worn off, and the French Guignol audience
  had declined to its regulars -- French university students necking in the
  balconies and American tourists!  
Perhaps
  most shockingly of all, despite his anti-censorship drumbeat -- Gordon
    never discusses censorship under Mussolini! Nor does he explain
  why Mussolini permitted the Italian Guignol's uninterrupted five-year run.  
It all
  sounds like Gordon tacked the censorship issue to the end of his book in
  a lame attempt at closure! 
  
    
    
 * Does the Grand Guignol Exist?
 
    Does
      the Grand Guignol still exist? Don't ask "theater professor" Mel
      Gordon -- he may not know!  
According
  to Gordon, Paris's Grand Guignol was demolished "in March 1963, [when]
  with much fanfare, the building that housed the Grand Guignol was totally
  destroyed." He even offers a detailed and colorful account. 
 But in The
  Monster Show (1993), horror scholar David J. Skal writes: "Contrary
  to one recently published account, the Grand Guignol was not demolished
  after its closing in 1964 [sic!], but still stands, now operating as a
  theatre school. In October 1989, this author was given a tour of
  the facility..." 
So who's
      right? Gordon or Skal? Gordon's Grand
        Guignol was first released in 1988, a revised edition in 1997 -- four years after
      Skal's The
        Monster Show! But Gordon's revised edition neither corrects his
      earlier edition, nor corrects Skal.  
 Gordon
  leaves the discrepancy unaddressed! 
Copyright 2003 by WeeklyUniverse.com 
  
  
    Vanessa Cortez is a Los Angeles based tabloid reporter who has investigated the occult underbelly of the entertainment industry. Read more about her journalism in Hollywood Witches.  | 
   
 
 |